Below is a list of statements from various elders against M Saad and the Fitna. These testimonies are an important source of truth as it seems unlikely that all these elders would be wrong while Maulana Saad alone is right. Most of these testimonies were written after the Nizamuddin Ramadhan 2016 Bloodshed (8 Proof Maulana Saad was the Mastermind). The elders have tried many ways to compromise and make peace.
NOTE: Before reading further, please understand that we aim to preserve the history of Tabligh. As time passes, this history may be forgotten, and the victims will be left without justice. We do not promote hate, and certainly not backbiting. See our article ‘Backbiting vs Warning‘. No matter how bad a Muslim is, he is still our Muslim brother. We love and hate only for the sake of Allah.
- Haji Abdul Wahab Sahab’s Statements
- What could be M Saad’s sin that he spoke such words?
- Saad should stop acting proud and taking Bay’at
- People of Nizamuddin must do Tawbah
- Maulana Saad himself has not spent even 40 days in Jamaat
- Maulana Zubair Kandhalawi 2006 Statement – The issue of Muntakhab Ahadith is very serious. Many people worry about it. This book has been translated into various languages without proper consultation
- Maulana Ibrahim Dewla’s Letter – In Nizamuddin, such a group has taken control and tries to present wrong things as right
- Maulana Ahmad Laat’s Recorded Testimony – I have copies of threatening letters sent to me. After investigation, it was clear that all this happened under Maulana Saad’s direction
- Maulana Yaaqub’s Letter – There is such chaos in Nizamuddin that has caused verbal fights, curses, and even brutal physical attacks
- Dr Khalid Siddiqui’s Letter – The Shura decided together that the work will continue under the Shura and not under one Ameer
- Chaudhry Amananullah (Nizamuddin Madrasa Shura) – Maulana Saad started the first-ever bloodshed in Nizamuddin during Ramadhan!
- Maulana Suhaib bin Maulana Zubair – Maulana Saad’s supporters have caused much damage today in Nizamuddin Markaz
- Joint Letter from Elders – If we keep supporting this wrong trend (M Saad) just to avoid conflict, this false approach would waste all our efforts, time, and wealth to support falsehood
- Mufti Zainul Abideen’s Son (Maulana Yusuf) – They tricked him and confused his mind, perhaps through magic or sorcery, damaged his thinking, and made him give wrong statements for their own gain
- Makkah/Madinah Elders – Maulana Saad threatened the peace-making group with violence!
- Maulana Shahed Saharanpuri – Ahwal Wa Atsar
- Clarification and Stance of Elders on accepting and sending Jamaats – All Shura Members