As-salāmu ‘alaykum.

My name is Mohammed, and I am from Ethiopia. I feel that the information you shared presents only one side and does not reflect the full reality. It lacks real evidence and gives a misleading picture.

Why was the true contribution and value of Maulana Saad for the Ummah not mentioned? Why was his sincere work and the positive impact of the Tablīgh effort ignored? Presenting only criticism without acknowledging the good is not fair and leads to misinformation.

We need the truth with balance and honesty, not information that sounds biased or hateful. Please present the complete picture so people can understand the reality properly.

Dont abuse allah is testing

Please have a read on the book ‘Ahwal Wa Atsar’ https://tablighi-jamaat.com/en/ahwal-wa-atsar-maulana-zubair-kandhlawi/

This book was written by Maulana Zakariyya’s grandson and Maulana Zubair’s closest friend.

It explains how thay have been tolerating Maulana Saad’s narcissism for years.

Read how much Maulana Zubair was crying due to the Sabr he had to undergo and conditions in the Markaz after Maulana Inamul Hasan’s demise.

The Ikhtilaf is a blessing in disguise as it has cut off the rotten tree from it’s roots.

Go botj

We provide evidence to all our claims. We are not looking to spread hate, we just want to find the truth.

I’ll just answer quickly here.

1) This effort is NOT a family business where controversial Saad and his kids control everything. We stick to clear recorded agreements. See: The 1995 Agreement.

2) The 2016 violence has been testified by many that Maulana Saad orchestrated it. He was caught lying red handed where he changed his story when things got out of hand. This single reckless event on the 13th of RAMADHAN sealed all hopes of mediation. See: Nizamuddin Ramadhan 2016 Bloodhsed

3) The issue is not about the changes. The issue is about the changes adone WITHOUT MASHWARA. I repeat WITHOUT MASHWARA. Reference: Ahwal Wa Athar Page 460

5) According to the Shura of Nizamuddin Madrasa, Maulana Saad is in full control of the Markaz accounts. These accounts were never audited. See: Chaudry Amantullah’s Account. Listen also to Maulana Ahmad Laat’s Testimony

1. On Leadership and Shura

Accusation: Maulana Saad violated the 1995 Shura agreement by declaring himself Ameer.

Defense:

• Maulana Saad is the direct descendant of the movement’s founders, and his leadership reflects continuity with the original vision.
• The Shura had become inactive and lacked quorum by 2014; Maulana Saad stepped in to prevent organizational paralysis A.
• Maulana Assad supported this transition to preserve unity and avoid fragmentation.

2. On Alleged Violence in 2016

Accusation: A violent purge occurred at Nizamuddin Markaz under Maulana Saad’s direction.

Defense:

• No formal charges or convictions were made against Maulana Saad or Maulana Assad for these events.
• The narrative of violence is largely anecdotal and politically amplified; Maulana Assad has consistently promoted peaceful resolution and dialogue.

3. On Ideological Deviations

Accusation: Maulana Saad introduced unapproved changes to the Jamaat’s doctrine.

Defense:

• The inclusion of Muntakhab Ahadith and other reforms were discussed with elders and aimed at enhancing accessibility and relevance F.
• Maulana Assad has emphasized that all decisions at Nizamuddin are made through mashwara (consultation), not autocracy F.

4. On COVID-19 Mismanagement

Accusation: Nizamuddin Markaz became a COVID-19 hotspot due to negligence.

Defense:

• The lockdown was sudden and poorly communicated; attendees were stranded unintentionally C.
• Maulana Assad and the Markaz cooperated with authorities during evacuation and medical screening.
• No charges were filed against Maulana Saad, and most foreign attendees were acquitted or deported after plea bargains C.

5. On Financial Transparency

Accusation: Lack of transparency in financial dealings and property ownership.

Defense:

• The Markaz operates as a waqf (endowment) and decisions are made collectively.
• Allegations of personal enrichment are speculative and not substantiated by legal findings F.

—

🌟 Positive Role of Maulana Assad

• Acts as a spiritual anchor and elder statesman within the Nizamuddin faction.
• Advocates for unity, humility, and adherence to the original mission of Tabligh.
• Maintains the sanctity of the Markaz as a center for da’wah and spiritual renewal.
• Supports reforms that enhance inclusivity, such as increased participation of women in Tabligh work