We’ve already written an article with regards to Mufti Taqi Usmani’s Statement => https://tablighi-jamaat.com/en/did-mufti-taqi-usmani-say-maulana-saad-is-on-haq/
Mufti Taqi was referring to the “method of Tabligh” difference, not his errors since in the same Audio, he mentioned “mistakes were made”.

With regards to Maulana Arshad Madani’s statement, we have written an article => https://tablighi-jamaat.com/en/arshad-madani-maulana-saad/.
Maulana Arshad Madani himself has explained his statement.

Why don’t you put the opinion of Maulana Arshad Madani on Maulana Saad not being gumrah and part of ahlas sunnah? As well as Mufti Isa’s? Why don’t you put Mufti Taqi’s opinion about both sides being right? You’re just picking and choosing what you want to put on your website. You’re misleading the public, and you will have to give a response to Allah on the day of judgement. Don’t risk it my brother, this is your aakhirah You’re messing around with. None of these shura members and elders will help you, I’m telling you. Fear Allah brother please. Don’t let shaytaan dilude you. Your heart wil never lie to you. Deep down, ask your heart if this website You’ve created is creating more good, or more evil, ask your heart this question.

You’re saying a rotating Ameer is permissible. Can you back it up from the lives of Sahabaah? You explained about the different mathaahib, and usool of fiqh which I completely understand, I follow the hanafi school of thought myself. But even the different school of thought, they have given their evidences from the Qur’aan, Sunnah, and lives of sahaabah. So all I’m asking for, is to provide evidence from the lives of Sahaabah that a rotating Ameer is permissible, this will end the discussion. You’re getting emotional and letting this get personal. I’m just asking 1 simple question, but you’re not answering it.

Provide us with the evidence from the lives of sahaabah that a rotating Ameer is permissible….

https://tablighi-jamaat.com/en/mufti-taqi-usmani-maulana-saad/#comment-2468

Nothing is as the same as before! Muslims were not the same as before, Tabligh was not the same as before. That’s just how time works.

Everyone who is reading these comments, can see how these website developers just want to spread disunity. They’re blind following these darul ulooms, without any evidence from the Qur’aan and Lives of Rasulullah ﷺ and Sahaabah

Hadhrat Abdullah ibn Mas’ood RA said that when you leave the sunnah, you will become misguided. The sunnah of management is having 1 fixed Ameer (Leader). Islaam is easy to understand. Stop making it complicated with mubah, makrooh and all these different terminologies that didn’t exist in the time of Sahaabah. We always say in our 6 sifaat, our success is in the way of Rasulullah ﷺ, any other way will lead to failure

You’re saying a rotating Ameer is permissible. Can you back it up from the lives of Sahabaah? You explained about the different mathaahib, and usool of fiqh which I completely understand, I follow the hanafi school of thought myself. But even the different school of thought, they have given their evidences from the Qur’aan, Sunnah, and lives of sahaabah. So all I’m asking for, is to provide evidence from the lives of Sahaabah that a rotating Ameer is permissible, this will end the discussion. You’re getting emotional and letting this get personal. I’m just asking 1 simple question, but you’re not answering it.

Provide us with the evidence from the lives of sahaabah that a rotating Ameer is permissible….

At this point I know you are just trolling but I will answer for the readers. I know many will just skim through the comment section.

It is called ‘Usool of Fiqh’ (أصول الفقه) which the Ulema/Mufti use to make rulings. Like the various Ameer/Shura implementations, there are so many things we cannot find the exact 100% practice in the lives of the Sahaba. This includes the rotating Shura Faisala system and Maulana Saad’s Family Dictatorship. Also, all the methodology in Tabligh like weekly Gasht, 3 days monthly Khurooj, etc, there is no exact practice of the Sahaba on this.

“There are so many things we cannot find exact 100% practice in the lives of the Sahaba. Can you show me Daleel for a family style dictatorship as practiced by Maulana Saad?”

All Tablighi Jamaat practices and the Shura are permissible (see comment here). They fall under the category of Permissible/Mubab (5 rulings: Compulsory/Fardh, Recommended/Sunnah, Permissible/Mubah, Disliked/Makrooh and Forbidden/Haraam). The methodology in our Madhabs are very consistent. Modern Salafis on the other hand are inconsistent. They have little due process in deriving rulings. Your constant questioning of ‘Where is Daleel’ mimics their behaviour.

“Disregarding Fiqh and going by literal understanding is the Pseudo-Salafi inconsistency and short-sightedness”

Since Shura is permissible, it is therefore impermissible to break an agreement and go against an existing administration to cause disunity. This is what Maulana Saad did including the bloodshed inside the Masjid.

“It is impermissible to break an agreement and go against a permissible and established administration. This causes disunity”

But at the end of the day…..I don’t think Tabligh i the purpose of your life. You live in the UK, a western country. You make good money and have a good job. Tabligh is just your side ‘thing’. You care less about what happens to Tabligh as long as your Dunya is ok and your pride is upheld. You made a wrong choice to jump into the Saad wagon and now you find it hard to humble yourself to the truth after the evidence came.

This is my final reply and that’s all I have to say.

show me from the lives of Sahaabah, that they had an Ameer rotating. From the lives of sahaabah please. You’re saying that a surah in the Qur’aan is named surah shuraa which is correct. You also mentioned that Hazrat Umar RA made a shura, which is also correct. But Umar RA was the only fixed Ameer of the shura. A shura has a fixed Ameer that doesn’t rotate. What the Aalmi Shura is doing, is that they’ve made a shura, but not a fixed Ameer. They’re rotating the Imaarat which is against the system that Sahabaah worked in